Tuesday, November 24, 2009

The Often Ignored Collectivism of Capitalism


Many have come to appreciate the very simple realities shared by this blog when one abandons ideology, partisanship and prejudice and logically attacks the issues of today. Partisans and one way thinkers are silly. We all appreciate that fact more when we concentrate without influence on a topic with good old fashioned common sense.

Here are a few simple realities many can't argue with nor agree upon:

1. Socialized Medicine. We already have socialized medicine. The insured pay the bills of the uninsured and under insured. Twenty-five dollar aspirin and rising deductibles, premiums and co-pays are the result of free medical procedures performed by hospitals on the indigent, under insured and uninsured. Our disagreement and inability to manage this reality causes tremendous inefficiency.

2. Mark to Market Accounting. There is no such thing as "mark to market." There is mark to transaction price accounting, but transaction prices aren't always correct. In the short run, transaction prices can run higher and lower than what a reasonable person would buy or sell for. The fallacy resides in the fact that it doesn't count those who refuse to come to the market at a said price, the silent majority. When prices are too high many buyers refuse to do business. When prices are too low many sellers avoid coming to the market. Mark to market only measures what those who are willing to do business under very specific conditions, sometimes unwillingly, are transacting at. As price points shift, often there are very different buyers and sellers who come to market. In other words, if one sale is made at x, and no other sales are made, the price would be x, even if ten thousand transactions would have occurred if the price was y. In the long run, values are functions of aggregate incomes and demands of society, not prices.

3. The back story to the stock market. There is no back story or information that is causal to stock prices. In any given day the only invariable truth is that there were more buyers than sellers or more sellers than buyers. The only reason financial news bears any relationship to stock price fluctuations is that the buyers and sellers believe that such stories are related. This results in a massive and naively trusting game of signaling. So long as, the majority of positions all "agree" to weight the news equally, short term fluctuations can be reasonably explained. That said, it's not the news - it's the agreed upon norm of how to act on such news that moves the price. In the end, its the buying and selling that moves price.

4. The market is always right. The market is nearly never right. Over long, LONG, periods of time, the averages of the market tend to support logical results. On any given day, the market is as wrong as any individual. It could be argued the market is further from truth than any free thinking individual in the tendencies of market participants to stampede in and out of positions moving equilibriums past proper price levels at neck breaking speed. If the real value is five and the market spends ten years at 2 and the subsequent 10 years at 8, than on average it was right even if it never maintained that value.

Of course we could go on and on, but it is important to land the plane on the point of this obvious exercise in logic. Regardless of which issue we speak of, the solution to inefficiency, breakdowns, inequity, fallacy, losses and failures is the point of agreement in society. All of our actions impact our fellow countrymen and women. When we agree, momentum is created, whether it be positive or negative. A point of agreement is anything from a sale to an appraisal. The willingness to stay in an upside down mortgage to ensuring all have access to affordable health care. A decision to place a put or call option on natural resources one doesn't require to thinking for oneself. We are our brothers keeper whether we believe that or not. Our failure to properly conduct ourselves in a positive manner shall manifest itself in the our reality.

Energy prices, home values, loan qualifications, joblessness, health care costs, profits and losses are our decisions collectively. They are the fruit of our actions. It is collectivism, or a positive point of agreement, that creates abundance. Our world is a manifestation of our collective perspective. Gold is not edible, usable or valuable in its own right, only by collective recognition and agreement of its value does it become an inflation hedge or an international currency. Whether collection of our individual efforts results in disruption, decay and depression or prosperity, innovation and hope is all decided by the direction of us as a mass. The apex is thus the superseding values of our population to act in self interest without detracting from the progress of society as a whole and influencing our families, neighbors, friends and coworkers to abide as well.